Love, Hate & Other Filters/ Born Confused

 

I thought it would be fun to do a ‘compare and contrast review of these two books, one published all the way back in 2004 and one to be published in January 2018.

I  loved both these books:  romance-driven, fun coming-of age stories of Indian (or South Asian) American girls, one Hindu, one Muslim, negotiating their way between two cultures and community. Both girls have a best friend who is white American and a run-in with a ‘suitable boy’ their parents adore (with varying results) and both girls are into photography/videography, Dimple in Born Confused takes photographs on her beloved film camera, while Maya in Love, Hate & Other Filters is never without her trusty digital video camera.

But let’s start with the covers.

Born Confused’s cover has had a number of iterations but basically has a ‘Bollywood’ style cropped poster of a film actress in (somewhat old fashioned) classically heavy make up with a sari border hiding her lower face.  Love, Hate…. on the other hand has a simpler cover: brown girl plus camera, with a faintly pink wall with some rangoli-type graffiti patterns behind it on the UK cover.

I loved Born Confused’s fun kitsch but imagine young readers will prefer the more generic YA cover of Love Hate & Other Filters? Identity is complicated, and young people working their way through it don’t necessarily want a cover that screams difference.

Both protagonists have great teen voices, Maya in LH &OF is more serious and restrained than Dimple in BC but also has more to contend with than identity issues and love triangles (the ‘hate’ part of the title.

Born Confused is a beautifully digressive, meandering  romp through the era (’90s in the UK, perhaps later in the US) when, briefly, Bollywood, bhangra and bindis were all the rage and not only for us brown people. I adored how everything from cultural appropriation to identity politics & transphobia were discussed and mulled over by (bless) poor confused Dimple. Dimple comes to realise that one’s identity is perhaps more like a ship, navigating through changing waters, with no absolutes but following one’s own star…

Post 9/11 and with the recent resurgence of ISIS, Islamophobia is a real issue in the West, encouraged by not only crazy fringe elements but the mainstream media and politicians. Muslim representation in children’s and YA has become a necessary corrective.

Love, Hate and Other Filters shows how Maya is in some ways perfectly secure in her Indian-Muslim American culture: she wears silk kurthis with jeans and has no hesitation passing on the ‘suitable boy’ her parents introduce her to. But Maya, like Dimple, is isolated in her almost all-white high-school environment and when a terrorist attack strikes a nearby town and the perpetrator is (wrongly) thought to be a Muslim the fear and pain of the hate Maya experiences is made very real…though (thankfully) with a happy if bittersweet ending.

I’d have loved reading these books in my distant teenage past and I’m so happy that my daughter and her friends will get to enjoy them both.

Born Confused by Tanuja Desai Hidier

Love, Hate & Other Filters by Samira Ahmed

Both 12+

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Ahimsa

30635597

Ahimsa is a rare thing: a historical novel about India aimed at children that doesn’t shy away from not only the harshness of British colonisation but also the horrible prejudice against Dalits, a very real problem in today’s India.

Anjali, our protagonist, is horrified when her mother joins Gandhi’s movement for Indian Independence, especially when it means she can no longer wear her pretty imported ghagra-cholis but only clothes made from homespun khadi. But when her mother insists on trying to help the children of a nearby Dalit settlement, Anjali finds her former prejudice challenged and becomes an advocate for opening up her local school to them.

Along the way she learns that standing up for what you believe in can be hard: when Mohan, a Dalit boy her age who has become her friend, is badly beaten by her neighbours and when her mother is jailed. There are no easy answers here, and although the novel ends on a note of hope, I found it painful reading. A great novel to read alongside your child and essential context for understanding colonialism. 10+

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

I Am Alfonso Jones

34099859

 

This is a marvellously executed journey through the life, death and afterlife of one Alfonso Jones, high-school student, Harlem resident, trumpet-player and bike messenger.  In the early pages of the book we get to know Alfonso as a kid, smart, funny, a history enthusiast who takes us on a tour of Harlem’s sites. We learn that his father has been in jail for Alfonso’s whole life on a wrongful charges and is about to be released due to new DNA evidence. We meet the friend he has a crush on, Danetta, and witness the beginnings of a hip-hop Hamlet his drama class are staging.

Devastatingly, Alfonso is shot by police while shopping for a new suit to wear at the welcome home party for his father. He finds himself aboard a ghost train, populated with other victims of police brutality, taking a ride back through his past, right from the circumstances of his own father’s wrongful arrest and his birth to his own funeral and the subsequent street protests and learning what the chant: ‘no justice, no peace’ means to these trapped souls.

This is all so real and might be overwhelmingly painful, were it not for Alfonso himself, who remains a funny, sassy, very real teen, attending open-mic nights in the afterlife to check no one else is moving on his gal Danetta and hanging around his home trying to make his mother aware of his presence.

The ending, as in real life, doesn’t give us any easy answers, but along the way Medina, Robinson and Jennings give us an education without sparing us the pain of loss and remembrance. 14+

Here’s a link to the book trailer

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Planet Middle School

 

Nikki Grimes’s Planet Middle School, originally published in 2011 comes out next year with a brand new cover. This short verse novel tells the tale of Joylin, a tomboy who likes her jeans, basketball and her friends KeeLee and Jake and her life just the way it is:

Up till now,

the math of my life

has been pretty simple:

friends

plus family

plus sports

What more

could I ask for, right?

But now Joy’s body is changing, she needs to wear a bra (yeuch) has a crush on the new boy at school, starts her period:

That’s a good name for it.

It’s the end of life

as I know it.

Grimes’s simple, elegant free verse deals deftly with changes: changing bodies, changing friendships and changing feelings. A great class text and a lovely, warm, immediate read for kids entering adolescence.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street

33413919

If you’re looking for the perfect Christmas present for a kid between seven and say eleven, the kind of kid who likes realistic stories with families, pets, enterprise, fun and perhaps a little heartbreak, I have found the book for you.

It looks beautiful with that gorgeous cover (there’s even a map!) Christmas day features prominently and more importantly it is beautifully told and imagined.

The Vanderbeekers are a family of diverse heritage with a mother, father, four girls and a boy and numerous pets, the star of this book being Paganini the rabbit. When their reclusive landlord, Mr Beiderman, who lives upstairs, decides not to renew their lease, the children unite in a campaign to save their home. Cue shenanigans: the kids involve the entire neighbourhood as well as a precious violin and a stray kitten as they uncover the truth about the Beiderman.

Gorgeous. 7+

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

When Morning Comes

30969181

 

When Morning Comes was published last year by Tradewind Books, a small Canadian publisher committed to multicultural children’s publishing and flew completely under my radar. It’s a timely novel, with nationalism, white oppression and the struggles of the marginalised making headlines in the US and the UK.

I was a child in the seventies, a teenager in the eighties and the anti-apartheid struggle was very much in the news and in our consciousness as we sang along to the Special AKA and stopped buying South African oranges.

But even I only had vague recollections of the Soweto uprising, without full knowledge of its historical context,  the utterly repressive regime it protested against and the trigger it became for the antiapartheid movement.

This is a fictional account told in four voices: two black teens from Soweto, Zanele and Thabo, Meena, a South African Indian schoolgirl and Jack a wealthy white kid. Reading it  was both an education and an eye-opener.

The novel is short, carefully crafted and told at a compelling pace with the protagonists’ voices remaining distinct, as these four kids from very different walks of life cross paths.

I don’t have a detailed enough knowledge of South Africa to comment on how authentic or otherwise the world depicted is, or how accurate the history is and I’d love to read some South African reviewer perspectives.

A really interesting read, a stunning debut and a book I’d like to see more widely talked about and read in the U.K. 12+

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Rebel Seoul

34931621._UY400_SS400_

Rebel Seoul has been described as Pacific Rim meets K-Drama, which is entirely valid, though the film it reminded me most of was Bladerunner.

I loved this futuristic action thriller’s dystopian rain-soaked feel and all the noir-ish elements–no one is quite who they seem to be.

Our hero is Lee Jaewon, abandoned son of a rebel father, who’s hidden his history, got himself out of gang life and into a sought-after military placement.

It turns out his assignment is to guard a top-secret project–a girl named Tera, with drug-induced superpowers–a supersoldier, for use in the continuous war that has raged in the Neo State (which comprises China, Japan and Korea) for decades.

Protecting Tera means loner Jaewon has to finally decide which side he’s on: rebel or state military. The story doesn’t shy away from ethical questions and complexities: smart teens may be sucked in by the video games, giant mecha and relationships but they’ll stay for the fast-paced plot and great protagonist.

A fantastic read for 12+

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment